Skip to content. Skip to navigation

FreeThink

Sections
Personal tools
You are here: Home The FreeThink Blog Archive 2007 July 06 A question of identity

A question of identity

by Peter Sloman last modified Friday, 6 Jul, 2007 09:59

Can politicians afford to be the last partisans left standing?

Several of today's political stories bring to the fore a question that has been rumbling on at least since the Scottish and Welsh elections in early May: the question of partisanship in the new political arena. Can politicians afford to maintain their traditional hostility to members of other parties at a time when party leaders want to appear inclusive and PR electoral systems require coalition?

Let's look at a couple of examples:

  • Some Labour peers are by all accounts apoplectic about the appointment of Sir Digby Jones as Minister for Trade Promotion and Investment, and they are unlikely to become much happier now that the Daily Mail has revealed Sir Digby's recent efforts to run for the London mayoralty with Conservative support. ('Labour's Digby "wanted to stand as Tory mayor"')
  • Labour activists also want to know why Quentin Davies, an old-school Tory Europhile whose instincts on social policy are distinctly authoritarian, feels at home in their party. As one Tory strategist put it at last week:

What makes the whole thing so infuriating, is that it just doesn’t make sense. There is no logic in Davies swapping sides. He is a socially conservative retard, appallingly illiberal. He is a bucket of bile. Nicholas Soames is probably more liberal. Why would someone like that join Labour? ('Here comes trouble')

  • Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, there is the continued reluctance of large elements in the Welsh Labour Party and the Welsh Lib Dems to enter a coalition Assembly government. First saw the All-Wales Accord / Triple Crown / Rainbow Coalition fall by the wayside as Lib Dems got cold feet about jumping in with the Tories; now Rhodri Morgan, who only weeks ago described his coalition options as "a choice between the inedible and the unpalatable" and claimed that Plaid were "unfit to run a cockle stall", is two special conference votes away from a red-green coalition - but not without sniping from several Labour MPs. Kim Howells accuses Morgan of "helping to deliver our communities into the hands of nationalist separatists and incompetents" ('Howells in attack on Plaid pact'), whilst Don Touhig calls the One Wales document electoral "suicide" ('Coalition means "suicide" for Labour'). Neither Labour, Plaid nor the Lib Dems can really claim much credit from these ill-tempered shenanigans.

Quentin Davies

Posted by James Graham at Friday, 6 Jul, 2007 12:02
"He is a socially conservative retard, appallingly illiberal. He is a bucket of bile. Nicholas Soames is probably more liberal. Why would someone like that join Labour?"

This question confuses me as it appears to answer itself.

Oh, sorry. We're not supposed to be tribal are we? :)
Tag cloud
Think Tanks | Opinion Polls | Devolved power | Hunting | Housing | Early years | Internet politics | Middle East | The Centreground | Women in Politics | Trident | Leadership | Defections | Nick Clegg | French elections | Next General Election | Higher Education | Youth | Foreign Policy | Military | Localism | Public Service Reform | Planning | Britain After Blair | Libertarian | right-wingers | Commentariat | Left/Right | Democracy | Prisons | John Reid | Home Office | Economy | Credit crunch | Liberal philosophy | Licensing laws | Islam and the UK | Coalitions | Labour positioning | Local elections | Hung Parliament | Neocons | Population | Anti-social behaviour | Aspiration | Positioning | Budget | Mark Oaten | British identity | Education | Brighton Conference 2006 | Prostitution | Constitutional reform | Welfare | Cameron | Welsh politics | Legislation | Environment | Short-termism | European politics | Journalists | Drugs | Ming Campbell | Immigration | House of Lords | Iraq | Lib/Lab | Apathy | CentreForum | Lib Dem policy | Courts and the law | media ownership | Family | North/South | Rebellions | Michael Gove | Nuclear power | Child protection | American elections | David Miliband | Atlantic politics | London elections | Globalisation | Proportional Representation | Academies | Taxation | Zimbabwe | NHS | Spin | Blogging | Gordon Brown | Far right | General Election | personality politics | Inequality | Demography | Long term care | Scottish politics | Steve Webb | Lib/Con | Orange Book
Log in


Forgot your password?
New user?
Blog Roll
Liberal Review
Liberal England
Love and Liberty
Lib Dem Voice
Liberal Polemic
Alex Foster
Alan Beddow
Alex Wilcock
Anders Hanson
Andrew Garner
Andrew Lewin
Andy Mayer
Ann Garner
Blogging 4 Wycombe
Chris Black
Chris Jenkinson
Chris Jennings
David Morton
David Rundle
David Spender
Duncan Borrowman
Edis Bevan
Heather Quinton
Iain Sharpe
Ian Ridley
Jock Coats
John Hemming
Jonathan Calder
Liberal Democrat Voice
Linda Jack
Louise Alexander
Lynne Featherstone
Mark Young
Millennium Elephant
Ming Campbell
Nick Barlow
Peter Black
Peter McGrath
Peter Pigeon
Richard Baum
Richard Gadsden
Richard Thomas
Sajjad Karim
Simon Isledon
Stephen Glenn
Will Howells
Archives
Syndication
Atom
RDF
RSS 2.0
Powered by Quills