Skip to content. Skip to navigation

FreeThink

Sections
Personal tools
You are here: Home The FreeThink Blog Archive 2008 May 30 Sacked for being too liberal or too rude?

Sacked for being too liberal or too rude?

by Russell Eagling last modified Friday, 30 May, 2008 10:32

There's an interesting story lurking around the bottom of the political pages (see 'Phil Collins bows out' in The Standard, 'Labour put on the path to tragedy, says Blair ally' in The Guardian and  'A tragedy is unfolding under Gordon Brown, says Labour adviser' in The Telegraph). Phil Collins, a speechwriter for James Purnell, has been told his services will no longer be required following an article he wrote for this month's Prospect magazine called 'Liberalise or die'.

The article contained two elements that might have been cause for dismissal.  Firstly, it was a little rude about Brown and his most loyal acolyte, Ed Balls.  Secondly, and more interestingly, it said that Labour needed to become more liberal.

"For New Labour to survive, it must become new liberal. The key dividing line in politics is no longer between left and right, but, increasingly, between liberal and authoritarian. The Labour government too often finds itself on the wrong side of this divide. One of the lessons Labour ought to have learned from 11 years in charge of the state is to be humble about the limits of that power. Another lesson is that the demands of individuals for more say in how public services are provided and delivered are growing stronger."

The article is quite succinct and well worth reading in full

It also makes an interesting companion piece to CentreForum's 'Lib-Lab' paper from October last year, which looked at the prospects of coperation between the two parties.  That concluded:

"Should Gordon Brown succeed in drawing the poison of the Iraq war from the British political debate, relations between the parties would inevitably improve.  If, at the same time, he was to display real leadership on the environment and a genuine willingness to disperse and decentralise power, the prospect of meaningful Lib Lab co-operation would again become real."

If Collins was dismissed because he was a little rude - the story doesn't mean much (apart from the fact that Labour can't take a joke at the moment).  If, however, he was dismissed because the people in Number 10 fundamentally disagree with the argument for decentralisation that Collins makes, the prospects for Lib Lab co-operation seem more remote now than they did last October.

Tag cloud
Think Tanks | Opinion Polls | Devolved power | Hunting | Housing | Early years | Internet politics | Middle East | The Centreground | Women in Politics | Trident | Leadership | Defections | Nick Clegg | French elections | Next General Election | Higher Education | Youth | Foreign Policy | Military | Localism | Public Service Reform | Planning | Britain After Blair | Libertarian | right-wingers | Commentariat | Left/Right | Democracy | Prisons | John Reid | Home Office | Liberal philosophy | Licensing laws | Islam and the UK | Coalitions | Labour positioning | Local elections | Hung Parliament | Neocons | Population | Anti-social behaviour | Aspiration | Positioning | Budget | Mark Oaten | British identity | Education | Brighton Conference 2006 | Prostitution | Constitutional reform | Welfare | Cameron | Welsh politics | Legislation | Environment | Short-termism | European politics | Journalists | Drugs | Ming Campbell | Immigration | House of Lords | Iraq | Lib/Lab | Apathy | CentreForum | Lib Dem policy | Courts and the law | media ownership | Family | North/South | Rebellions | Michael Gove | Nuclear power | Child protection | American elections | David Miliband | Atlantic politics | London elections | Globalisation | Proportional Representation | Academies | Taxation | Zimbabwe | NHS | Spin | Blogging | Gordon Brown | Far right | General Election | personality politics | Inequality | Demography | Long term care | Scottish politics | Steve Webb | Lib/Con | Orange Book
Log in


Forgot your password?
New user?
Blog Roll
Liberal Review
Liberal England
Love and Liberty
Lib Dem Voice
Liberal Polemic
Alex Foster
Alan Beddow
Alex Wilcock
Anders Hanson
Andrew Garner
Andrew Lewin
Andy Mayer
Ann Garner
Blogging 4 Wycombe
Chris Black
Chris Jenkinson
Chris Jennings
David Morton
David Rundle
David Spender
Duncan Borrowman
Edis Bevan
Heather Quinton
Iain Sharpe
Ian Ridley
Jock Coats
John Hemming
Jonathan Calder
Liberal Democrat Voice
Linda Jack
Louise Alexander
Lynne Featherstone
Mark Young
Millennium Elephant
Ming Campbell
Nick Barlow
Peter Black
Peter McGrath
Peter Pigeon
Richard Baum
Richard Gadsden
Richard Thomas
Sajjad Karim
Simon Isledon
Stephen Glenn
Will Howells
Archives
Syndication
Atom
RDF
RSS 2.0
Powered by Quills