Search

FreeThink RSS Feed

FreeThink Comment Blog
Taking your foot off the accelerator too soon PDF Print E-mail
Written by Giles Wilkes   
Tuesday, 23 June 2009 12:54

When should policy makers start to withdraw the stimulus? 

Christine Romer in the Economist digs up an historical analogy that Paul Krugman is fond of: the way FDR precipitated a mini-Depression in 1937-8 by going for a balanced budget too soon, and also tightening monetary conditions. She warns against holding back on stimulus until we are returning to full employment.  Paul Samuelson too argues for the stimulus to be sustained.  Perhaps the green shoots we are seeing are only, um, shooting because of the expectation that the stimulus will last.

Similar reasoning helps explain why Wolfgang Munchau is so furious about the Berlin Hairshirt. A constitutional commitment to a tight fiscal policy is crazy.  What if Germany does not resume growth at a healthy pace? Munchau writes:

"This general level of debt-aversion is bizarre. Many ordinary Germans regard debt as morally objectionable, even if it is put to proper use. They see the financial crisis primarily as a moral crisis of Anglo-Saxon capitalism. The balanced budget constitutional law is therefore not about economics. It is a moral crusade, and it is the last thing, Germany, the eurozone and the world need right now."

This is one reason for our aversion to the Conservatives' Office for Budget Responsibility.   In certain circumstances - say, when the economy is growing, there is a surplus and a large debt to repay - having a Victorian Uncle tutting over the Chancellor's shoulder about debt repayment may make sense.  But what about during another downturn? Fiscal policy is a matter for judgement, not dogma.  You may hear more reasons for this aversion on Sunday in Westminster Hour, for which I was interviewed. 

One reason to slam on the fiscal brakes might be long-term interest rates getting out of control (see earlier discussion about Niall Ferguson's views here).  When the economy is at capacity, public and private growth start to compete against one another.   But there seems to be a reasonable consensus behind the idea that the recent rise in rates is benevolent, reflecting higher future growth.  Paul Krugman, obviously, agrees.  However, David Smith discusses Mervyn King's views and hints that rates might rise faster than people currently expect.

One day we will have to deal with the structural fiscal deficit - we have a big paper coming out on the subject soon. Public spending cuts will surely play a part.  But I am amazed at the unbalanced hostility that the FT shows towards the public sector in this info-graphic. Phrases like "unsustainable leviathan" beg the question.  Few analysts point out how the loss of revenues and a collapse in nominal GDP are the immediate cause of the debt explosion.  We will.  

The other big issue is the future of banking regulation.  There is a growing consensus behind the idea of a wise systemic regulator solving problems in future.  No more will regulators just look at individual companies: instead, they will analyse the whole universe of financial entities, and work out when it looks likely to blow up the world, again. 

Hmm.  I'm glad someone is kicking back against this idea, or at least asking it questions.  John Plender:

"Heavy reliance, then, is being placed on the ability of this new regulatory approach to prevent a future global financial crisis. Yet there is no agreement on how it might work in practice and good reason to question whether it will live up to its advance billing. One very senior former member of the global central banking establishment even says “not only is macro-prudential regulation rubbish, but it gives rubbish a bad name

Capital requirements that track the cycle, together with overall leverage ratios, are thus central planks of the macro-prudential approach. Yet the attempt to counter pro-cyclicality raises huge questions, most notably on the issue of whether regulators should have discretion to change capital requirements in the course of the cycle or whether the capital regime should be subject to pre-determined rules. In a perfect world, giving discretion to regulators to calibrate capital requirements according to the state of the economy makes sense. In the real world, regulators would face the ever-difficult problem of defining where they were in the economic cycle.”.

Precisely.   An excellent letter today makes a similar point. 

"Virtually nobody within the commercial banks themselves recognised the danger of what they were putting on their balance sheets. How could one expect a regulator, whose information is not nearly as complete, to ascertain a problem? Not a single central banker in the last episode noticed the crisis before it was already manifest. "  Well said, Thomas Dempsey, Chadds Ford, PA, US

But Ric Mishkin disagrees. 

 

Comments (22)
great
1 Thursday, 11 February 2010 03:30
thanks for the insightful post. I look forward to reading more from you.
great
2 Saturday, 06 March 2010 05:31
You have the best feeling of comfort. You never be willing to take them
off. ( http://www.inuggshopping.com )
po
3 Thursday, 08 April 2010 10:11
To recommend a wonderful puma store http://www.pumashoesale.com , where you can find the perfect puma ferrari shoes. Nothing is impossible, come on, to get the best puma sneakers, enjoy shopping.
adidas
4 Saturday, 10 April 2010 01:20
The aim of Adidas shoes is to make the very best adidas superstar shoes at an affordable price.cheap Adidas shoes of running sneakers is about a lifestyle. Always making style and innovative advances, cheap Adidas shoes have the fashionable running shoes you will love.From inexpensive adidas running shoes to competitive track shoes, the Adidas superstar sneakers offer great value.

http://www.adidas-cheap.com/
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-campus-c-3.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-forum-mid-c-10.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-nizza-hi-c-11.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-rod-laver-c-13.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-shooting-star-c-12.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-stan-smith-c-5.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-superstar-c-6.html
polo shirt
5 Monday, 12 April 2010 08:34
Replica NBAjerseys are becoming rapidly popular as regular attire.You will notice many teenagers donning a Bill Russell orCheapNFLjerseys Oscar Robertson jersey in pubs, colleges and discos.
In fact, NFLjerseys even individuals who areMLBjerseys
not NFL fans have started wearing these jerseys as a style statement.
NHLjerseys are only the beginning in terms of what you can expect to find online now.
polo shirt
6 Monday, 12 April 2010 08:34
Replica nfl jerseys are becoming rapidly popular as regular attire.You will notice many teenagers donning a Bill Russell or Oscar Robertson jersey in pubs, colleges and discos.
In fact, nfl jerseys even individuals who are not NFL fans have started wearing these jerseys as a style statement.
Wholesale jerseys are only the beginning in terms of what you can expect to find online now.
coach handbags
7 Monday, 19 April 2010 11:38
Coah Bags are known as fashion bags,Coach Crossbody Bags, Cheap Coach Backpacks and Discout Coach Totes are included.
edhardy-us
8 Tuesday, 04 May 2010 06:15
ed hardy clothing, ed hardy clothing
supra womens muska skytop, supra womens muska skytop
wholesale headphone,ipod
9 Wednesday, 26 May 2010 06:45
MBT SHOSE
JORDAN SHOSE
NIKE AIR FORCE ONE SHOSE
ADDIDAS SHOSE
AIR YEEZY SHOSE
NIKE SHOX SHOSE
PUMA SHOSE
UGG
TIMBERLAND SHOSE
YVESSAINTLAURENT high-heel for lady
Christian Louboutin high-heel
gucci boot for lady
chanel sheepskin fashion shose for lady
leisure shose for lady
LV handbag and wallet
CHANEL handbag and wallet
GUCCI handbag and wallet
Burberry handbag and wallet
COACH handbag and wallet
dior handbag and wallet
ED HARDY handbag and wallet
PRADA handbag and wallet
juicy handbag and wallet
Wholesale LUGGAGE
wholesale all brand fashion jewelly for lady
10 Wednesday, 26 May 2010 07:27
TIFFANY JEWELRY
CHANEL JEWELRY
DIOR JEWELRY
LINK JEWELRY
ARMANI SUNGLASSES
CHLOE SUNGLASSSES
POLICE SUNGLASSES
CHANEL SUNGLASSES
OKELY SUNGLASSES
CARTIER SUNGLASSES
wholesale mlb jerseys
11 Friday, 11 June 2010 00:17
Thank you for your sharing.I'm very interested in wholesale mlb jerseys.There are so many famouse mlb stars jerseys,we have Derek Jeter Jerseys.So I an fascinated to the Chase Utley Jerseys,no matter any one of mlb stars juse like Joe Mauer Jerseys and Dustin Pedroia Jerseys,which are my best witness as the Albert Pujols Jersey fans!jerseys.There are so many famouse mlb stars jerseys,we have Derek Jeter Jerseys.So I an fascinated to the Chase Utley Jerseys,no matter any one of mlb stars juse like Joe Mauer Jerseys and Dustin Pedroia Jerseys,which are my best witness as the Dustin Pedroia Jerseys fans!
wholesale nfl jerseys
12 Friday, 11 June 2010 00:17
It was a very nice idea! Just wanna say thank you for the information you have shared wholesale nfl jerseys. Just continue writing this kind of post.
supra shoes
13 Tuesday, 15 June 2010 08:57
http://www.airjordans2010.com
http://www.jordanfly.com
http://www.needghd.com
http://www.ghdpower.com
http://www.mbtshoeskicks.com
http://www.edhardyusastore.com
http://www.airmbtshoes.com
http://www.radiisneakers.com
Moncler Jackets
14 Sunday, 27 June 2010 14:12
Welcome to Moncler Jackets online shop.The 2010 latest and most fashionable Moncler vest,A selection of popular Moncler coats are shown on our store.If you are looking for Moncler boots, here is the perfect opportunity.

Moncler brings summer special designed products Moncler T-shirts.Moncler shirts are made from 100% cotton,very comfortable to wear.

Our aim is to provide customers high-quality products and excellent after-sales service.save up to 60% off. 7 days delivery to worldwide with free shipping.
mbt
15 Saturday, 03 July 2010 02:27
mbt
it is a great post ,thanks for your share.
Air Jordans
16 Friday, 09 July 2010 02:30
sdsfsfsfsfs
tiffany and co
17 Friday, 09 July 2010 08:36
http://sneakerace.com jordan shoes, nike shoes
http://www.sportemall.com/ NFL Jerseys
http://www.gainbling.com/ Tiffany and Co, Cheap Tiffany
http://www.originalace.uk.com/ Adidas shoes
http://www.luxuryou.uk.com/ Cartier Jewelry
Hermes Birkin
18 Thursday, 15 July 2010 08:36
Money can`t buy Happiness? Whoever said that doesn`t know where to buy.
Buyhermesbirkin offers the high quality Hermes bags and services.
No matter it is the classic Birkin bag, or the Kelly and Lindy bag,
or the latest new designs, you can find them here. Just selecting one,
you will be the next Victoria in the street. – Comes from Shuna Sun
youth nfl jerseys
19 Friday, 16 July 2010 08:26
nfl jerseys
youth nfl jerseys
custom nfl jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
nfl authentic jerseys
nfl throwback jerseys
80% OFF sale by Year limited
20 Tuesday, 20 July 2010 01:42
welcome here to hava a look ,you wil find what you want for girls..happy to your account from I !
[url=http://www.christianlouboutinshoesmall.com/]christian louboutin[/url] shoes online 80% OFF
[url=http://www.christianlouboutinshoesmall.com/]christian shoes[/url]
ugg boots on sale
21 Wednesday, 28 July 2010 01:46
http://www.uggvipshop.com
UGG Classic Tall
UGG Classic Short Boots
UGG Classic Cardi
UGG Classic Mini
UGG Ultra Tall
UGG Classic Metallic
UGG Sundance II
UGG Bailey Button
UGG Bailey Button Boots
UGG Argyle Knit Boots
UGG Classic Tall Boots
UGG Romantic Flower Boots
UGG Nightfall Boots
UGG Slippers
UGG Ultra Short Boots
http://www.uggvipshop.com
Nike Air Max 90
22 Thursday, 29 July 2010 01:45
welcomwelcome to buy fivefingers kso
Free shipping, cheaper price ,discount
here have other shoes just for you:
Nike Air Max 90
Nike Air Max 95
Nike Basketball Shoes
Nike sandals
fivefingers kso
nike runing shoes
puma shoes
nike acg sandals
Last Updated ( Tuesday, 23 June 2009 18:14 )