FreeThink Comment Blog
The President's Chair of Economic Advisors defends Deficits PDF Print E-mail
Written by Giles Wilkes   
Thursday, 02 July 2009 13:05

As I commented last week, Christine Romer, key Obama advisor, has defended deficits in a recession and warns against consolidating too soon.

You may also be familiar with the work of Greg Mankiw, a conservative economist, now frequently warning in his mildmannered way against public healthcare, but also on the lookout for dangerous fiscal deficits, and sceptical about their ability to boost economic growth.

Mark Thoma finds a speech from the Chair of the Council of Economic Advisers to the President, which defends running a deficit when there are strong economic headwinds:

Of course, the expansionary effects ... will be offset to some degree by the effects of the budget deficits that arise... Deficits can raise interest rates and crowd out of investment, although I should note that the magnitude of this effect is much debated in the economics literature. The main problem now facing the U.S. economy is not high interest rates...

The Administration would prefer not to have deficits, but deficit reduction is only one of many goals. ... Deficits are worrisome, but not as worrisome as an economy that is not growing and is rapidly shedding jobs. ...

Spot on. 

But the Chair of the Council in question is Greg Mankiw in 2003, not Keynesian Christine in 2009.  Seems that when the deficits come from tax cuts largely enjoyed by the rich,  conservative economists can more easily believe in 'very conventional short-run stabilization policy: You can find it in all of the leading textbooks.' 

If high interest rates were not the problem in 2003, I fail to see how they could be now. 

The next time we have a major structural deficit, it will probably come from a right-leaning government cutting taxes too far.  Things move in cycles -  perhaps the next mistake will be overestimating the positive Laffer-effects from cutting high marginal taxes (though, for the record, I agree with this rather good explanation of the elasticity effects of the 50p rate from none other than Fraser Nelson. Scrapping this band will not cost much money.  Where I doubt we agree is on replacing it with other forms of wealth tax). 

Comments (4)
deficit
1 Saturday, 04 July 2009 04:55
Many countries are having budget deficit, these are just some of the common scenario since recession occurred. Even the ordinary household are still suffering with the same problem. They have to ask Why can't I get my cash now?" Well, if you're that person, asking themselves "Why can't I get my cash now?" then ask yourself what happened. If you can't get the amount of your cash now that you'd like, because you had to spend more than you thought on an unexpected expense, and you need some budget support, then you can apply for a faxless loan through a payday lender, as many take applications over the phone or over the internet, and use direct deposit to wire the funds. It's not a reward, it's a cash advance to tide you over until pay day, if you ask how to get my cash now?"
cheap mbt shoes
2 Friday, 25 December 2009 20:05
Today,a good shoes to a people is more and more important.Let me tell you something about MBT shoes.[url=http://www.showcu.com]MBT Anti Shoes[/url] have been known as the world’s smallest gym.Since they increase muscle activity,strenthening and toning of the leg,buttock,stomach and back muscles takes place during everyday activities like walking and standing.
Since celebrities like Cher,Gwyneth Paltrow,and Heidi Klum have reportedly added [url=http://www.showcu.com]Anti Shoes[/url] to their shoe collection,[url=http://www.showcu.com]MBT Shoes[/url] have received a lot of press.Their unique design has supposedly help wearer’s tone up,lose weight,and even smooth cellulite,and it has garnered the brand a lot of attention as well.
Shop your MBT Anti Shoes on Showcu of [url=http://www.showcu.com]Mbt Shoes Sale[/url].We are the stockist of Cheap Anti Shoes.Our Anti Gravity Shoes Sale in huge stock.You can enjoy Free Shipping on our MBT Anti UK and [url=http://www.showcu.com]MBT US[/url].Buy Now!
MBT US
3 Saturday, 26 December 2009 11:28
The Cubs used the long-ball to their advantage tonight. DeRo, DLee and The Riot all hit homeruns to lead the Cubs in Dusty Baker's return to Chicago. Ryan Demspster didn't have his best outing(5 walks), but he still got a quality start and his second win of the year. The Cubs pulled ahead for good with 3-run HR by Lee in the bottom of the 5th. Mike Fontenot made a sweet diving stop up the middle to keep the Reds from tying the game and on the next play Carlos Marmol induced Ken Griffey's Jr. into an inning-ending double play. Marmol was straight flithy tonight and Kerry Wood shut down the Reds in the 9th. Go Cubs Go! Big Z on the hill tomorrow!
great
4 Saturday, 06 March 2010 05:38
I f y o u t h in k o u r w e b s i t e i s g o od , y ou c an p ut th is web sit e t o book ma rks or ot her pl aces, ea sy t o fi nd ...
Last Updated ( Thursday, 02 July 2009 14:29 )