Related Posts
Search
FreeThink RSS Feed
| Cameron Isn't Thatcher |
|
|
|
| Written by Giles Wilkes |
| Wednesday, 29 April 2009 08:49 |
|
In my letter to the FT today, I take issue with the implication in Philip Stephens' article of the day before, which tries to draw parallels between Brown and the divisive 1970's. Therefore: "Mr Cameron has been studying the early 1980s to see how Margaret Thatcher’s government handled its dismal inheritance after the 1979 election" But the differences between these eras easily outweigh the similarities (read the letter). Some might protest that this is obvious: surely politicians will not sleep-walk into the same policies that seemed to work 30 years before? But the debate on fiscal policy is tangled, mired in politics and far from achieving any kind of consensus: read the exchange between Kobayashi and Krugman on the Japanese experience, and this snippet from a voluminous debate triggered by Eugene Fama claiming that national accounting identities somehow prove that fiscal stimulus cannot stimulate. (For the record, I think Andy Harless has done the most thorough job of destroying this fallacy; Greg Mankiw presents a more reasonable conservative case than Fama). Against this backdrop of conflicting advice, and with few politicians as confident with macroeconomics as Nigel Lawson was, it is depressingly easy to imagine them falling for some sort of rough rule of thumb, like "It worked for Maggie" or "Those 364 economists were wrong in 1981* - therefore they would be wrong now. Cutting government spending will boost confidence." Unfortunately, in the context of a financial/asset price crunch, the government is currently the only provider of economic demand: even The Economist , hardly an enemy of free markets, sees this. Cutting the government's contribution to demand too soon, for ideological reasons or because of a false belief in it 'crowding out' private markets, might restart the demand-deflation spiral just as we start to recover from it. Of course, the size of the fiscal mess will still make the decision terribly hard: but (ironically) the risk of a gilt-market stop will only become real once financial investors recover the confidence to invest in other instruments - i.e. when the private economy has started to show some life. It will be a tough call. But too soon might risk repeating what FDR did in 1938: cut back too soon and strangle the recovery. Let's hope that a new government pays attention to the conditions of 2010, not 1980, when it makes this call. *I recommend Nigel Lawson's enormous memoir of his time in the Treasury as a guide to the government thinking of that era. Nigel Lawson was once the editor of the Spectator. It is rather depressing to contrast his expertise with the simple-minded thinking that constitutes public debt analysis there nowadays. Hopefully it is no longer the incubator of future Chancellors. |
| Last Updated ( Thursday, 21 May 2009 15:47 ) |



http://www.adidas-cheap.com/
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-campus-c-3.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-forum-mid-c-10.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-nizza-hi-c-11.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-rod-laver-c-13.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-shooting-star-c-12.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-stan-smith-c-5.html
http://www.adidas-cheap.com/adidas-superstar-c-6.html
Cheap Prom Dresses
Buy Prom Dresses
Plus Size Prom Dresses
Plus Size Prom Dress
Short Prom Dresses
Short Prom Dress
Vintage Prom Dresses
Vintage Prom Dress
Sexy Prom Dresses
Sexy Prom Dress
Simple Prom Dresses
Simple Prom Dress
Designer Prom Dresses
Designer Prom Dress
Quinceanera Dresses
Quinceanera Dress
has a 1 ceramic standard width plate so is perfect for straightening and creating flicks.
leBron air force one is the best seller in our online store.
Buy kobe 1 from online store which supported 24/7 service.
air max I - good quality and cheap.
Every jordan countdown pack is the best ones.
good bailey button ugg will come to you in return.
http://www.jordanfly.com
http://www.needghd.com
http://www.ghdpower.com
http://www.mbtshoeskicks.com
http://www.edhardyusastore.com
http://www.airmbtshoes.com
http://www.radiisneakers.com
hollister
hollister clothing
http://www.sportemall.com/ NFL Jerseys
http://www.gainbling.com/ Tiffany and Co, Cheap Tiffany
http://www.originalace.uk.com/ Adidas shoes
http://www.luxuryou.uk.com/ Cartier Jewelry
Chanel Hobo Bags & Chanl purses
Chanel outlet,Chanel 2.55 handbags
Chanel purse & Chanel outlet
Chanel handbags & Chanel 2.55 handbags
lLouis vuitton handbags sale 2010.
Coach is the maker of luxury lifestyle handbags. Find the best selections of coach purses and
coach bags here! We offer the best collection of coach handbags with the best price including shipping.welcome to enjoy coach bags,cheap and discount coach outlet,retailer and Wholesale Distributor.discount coach bags on sale.
Explore the world of juicy couture handbags,top quality of juicy couture HandBags are provided for our customer.Cheap juicy handbags is the world's most irreverent, fun, and on-trend lifestyle brand for women and girls of all ages. Enjoy a great selection of discount juicy couture handbags.juicy couture handbag on sale,free shipping,110% price guarantee.
Burberry is a British luxury fashion house,manufacturing clothing and fashion accessories.burberry handbags are known for their high quality,burberry bags on sale look so pretty and fashionable.Enjoy fahsion and durable discount burberry handbags on sale & Burberry bags in best quality but lowest price.
Marc Jacobs handbags offer an array of looks that are not only stylish, but are fashionably functional as well.This colourful offering from renowned Marc Jacobs handbags has a multitude of flap pockets and a comfortable shoulder strap.Marc by
Marc Jacobs bagshandpicked by a global community of independent trendsetters and stylists.welcome to enjoy designer Marc Jacobs handbags sale 2010.
Uggs Outlet http://www.agogouggs.com/
Free shipping, cheaper price ,discount
here have other shoes just for you:
Nike Air Max 90
Nike Air Max 95
Nike Basketball Shoes
Nike sandals
fivefingers kso
nike runing shoes
puma shoes
nike acg sandals